05212013Headline:

An Ahmadi’s Open Letter to Pakistani Media

open_letter_ahmadiyya

Dear friends in the media,

Salutations,

I’m a Pakistani Ahmadi Muslim. I know you haven’t read these three words in a single sentence because of an amendment made to the constitution of our country that precludes the composition of such a statement; legally! Still, I have to be what I am. This trinity of nationality-sect-religion is experienced by most of you but I am the only one who is not allowed to venture in this domain of nomenclature. While many of you can easily be Pakistani Sunni Muslims or Pakistani Shia Muslims or even Pakistan Braelvi Muslims and Pakistani Deobandi Muslims, it’s me who is referred to as a Qadiani or a Mirzai without any difficulty and without even knowing that these titles are derogatory and discriminatory and even offensive in your writings and on your nine o’clock TV shows.

I know you are all good law abiding citizens my dear friends, and the second amendment of 1974 prevents you from calling me an Ahmadi Muslim but does not ask you to label me as traitor, conspirator, Zionist, infidel, apostate etc which you knowledgeably or otherwise often do.

My second concern arose when all of you, yes essentially all, while reporting the barbarous incident of May 28, 2010 called our mosques “places of worship”. Yes they were places of worships where our community members were offering the Friday prayers as the terrorists struck while the Friday sermon was underway. We also offer the prayers of Fajar, Zohar, Asar, Maghrib and Isha in the same “places of worship”. You’ll also be amazed to know that we pray both the Eids there and the building incidentally faces the Holy Kaa’ba in Makkah and has grown a Minaret and a Dome which was visible in the background as they filled the ambulances with the dead bodies of my brothers. But as I said there is a law that has to be followed.

The clause that apparently stopped you from calling a spade a spade was introduced by General Zia in 1984 and now is proudly the Section 298(B)(1)(d) of the Penal Code of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan.

I’ve copy pasted this section of the law below:

298-B. Misuse of epithets, descriptions and titles, etc., reserved for certain holy personages or places:

(1) Any person of the Quadiani group or the Lahori group (who call themselves ‘Ahmadis’ or by any other name who by words, either spoken or written, or by visible representation-

(d) refers to, or names, or calls, his place of worship a “Masjid”;

shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years, and shall also be liable to fine.

Now my law-respecting friends please read the above clause. The law only stops me from calling my mosque a mosque and suggests a three year prison term for this crime. You as a ‘Constitutional and Full Muslim’ are allowed doing so but you didn’t.

I urge you to please get off the band wagon that is being driven by the Mullah Cult and is hell bound. I ask you to please respect my religious sentiments and not act immaturely because further oppressing the already oppressed will gain you nothing.

I have been facing such columns and TV shows, well actually my parents have been facing them and soon my children will be facing the same anchors, writers and analysts. It hurts. Yes it hurts when you flow your blood in the roots of a country to defend it, when you speak for hours and hours in the UN General Assembly to acquire a diplomatic superiority for your motherland, when you sit in the frozen labs of Italy to pin a Nobel Prize to the green flag, when you use your ink and quill to create the best literature and poetry and bring pride to you and all those fellow citizens who side with the pen. If you are who side with the pen my friends then please also be among those who side with it justly.

Yours Faithfully,

Citizen of Pakistan  |   A victim of State and Media oppression   |   An Ahmadi Muslim

AL-Ufaq

88 Responses to "An Ahmadi’s Open Letter to Pakistani Media"

  1. Ahmad Kamal Rahman says:

    Dear Atif, hats off to you man. A really nice, precise and to the point letter.

    May Allah Almighty keeps you under His protection and helps you with your pen.

    Take care and keep it up Bro!

    Allah Hafiz

    KAmal

  2. awesome piece of writing… voice of every ahmadi`s heart…!!

  3. Pareeze says:

    Atif very weldone! God bless you.

  4. Faraz Cheema says:

    i have’nt word’s to appreciate you…grrrreeeeat.

  5. Good job may almighty Allah bless u. says:

    This is the right time to tell all these mullaz that we are the only torch bearers of true islam.so,come out from darkness.

  6. Ahsan says:

    Dear brother Atif
    I am happy to see your article and I appreciate you to write these type of articles, this is over voice with pen and this is the only the way to realize the people who are responsible for these types of cases.

    May ALLAH protects our Jammat and All the good people in this world .

  7. Khalid Hayat says:

    Assalamo Alaikum Atif, A well written letter indeed but unfortunately written to the deaf, dum and blind whose hearts have been sealed and brainwashed by the Mullahs, who preach to the brainless to kill and be killed to recieve unlimited Hoors in the next life. I wish that these Mullahs would practice what they preach and get all the hoors for themselves and leave the illiterate public to live in peace and harmony with their fellow human beings.
    May Allah have mercy on all Pakistanis and enable them to wake up and stand up in unity against the evil Mullahs and the corrupt polititions of their country. Ameen.

    • M. ABID ALAM says:

      SHUT UP BASETERD DEAF AND BLINDS ARE ONLY YOUR COMMUNITY ONLY UR SECT U R ALL DESERVED FOR PUNISHMENT BY GOD….

      • DONT WANT TO WRITE says:

        MASHAALLAH WHAT A BRILLIANT COMMENT. THIS IS WHAT IS EXPECTED FROM YOU ………WHAT SHOULD I CALL YOU? YOU CHOOSE YOURSELF.

      • Mr. Aya Nosho says:

        I did not know that new name for ‘god’ is ‘M. ABID ALAM.’
        Oh Pakistani god a creation of Pakistani National Assembly. M. ABID ALAM can you create a leg of a mosquito….You may be winner of gold Medal from Univ. of Terrorism…..A MSG From North America

      • AFIA REHMAN says:

        WESE AP JO HMEIN GALIAN NIKAL RAHE HN LGTA HAI AP NE HADEES NI SUNI K MUSLMAN KA GAALI DENA SBSE BARA GUNAAH H AUR MUSLMAN WO NAHI JIS K HAATH AUR ZUBAAN SE DOOSRE MHFOOZ NA RAHEIN.

  8. Maria says:

    Assalamo Alaikum,

    Very well written article. You have captured the sentiments of so many. Excellently worded, and the best part about it is that it is not offensive to who it is addressed. That is the thing about Ahmadi Muslims. We are those that no matter how much others insult us or hurt & harm us, we never say or do anything hurtful back. “Galiyaan sun kar dua do, paa kar dukh aaram do” – those are the words we abide by. And this letter showcases that brilliantly. JazakAllah. May Allah the Almighty protect all the Ahmadis in Pakistan, and always keep them within His care.

  9. Khuram Munib says:

    Dear brother!
    Very impressive and very well communicated.. “Allah karay zor-e-qalam aur zyada”

    Regards

  10. Fateh cheema says:

    Well done brother…what you wrote are actually feelings of every Ahmadi Muslim…God Bless you

  11. Shahbaz Qamar says:

    Very well articulated Atif Saab. May Allah guide them to the righteous path and keep every Ahmadi Muslim under his protection.

  12. Thankyou very much everyone for your comments and appreciation. We, Ahmadi Muslims believe in “Jihad of the pen”. So it’s our duty as a Muslim to spread the message of Peace, Tolerance and Human Rights as much as we can. I expect everyone to contribute as much as possible

    Jazakallah
    Atif

  13. Zafar imran says:

    Hats off to you for the words of an ahmadi’s heart. Kaashh keii dill main uttarr jayee merrii baatt!!!

  14. Atif Malik says:

    Dear Atif,

    You have articulated well your point of view, may Allah open the eyes and ears of those it’s intended and bring them out from their respective silence, hiding, ignorance and deliberate lies.

    Surely, many can already see their end game is not the annihilation of law abiding Ahmadis but to instil a fundamental-Islamic-totalitarianism. An Islamic state should be a shining example to the world of how beautiful Islam is, not what it is today, a constitutionally oppressive and closed society.

    Pakistani brothers and sisters, now is the time for united action, to stand up and protest against the constitution, to protest against all radicalism. Arabs (Tunisia and Egypt) are bravely standing up against oppressive regimes, but we have also successfully done so through non-aggressive protest sixty+ years ago against the British. So we know it can be done, don’t be afraid, stand up and let your majority voice be heard.

    Praying for our motherland.

    A fellow patriot,

    Atif M

    • Shafique Ahmed says:

      A person who didn’t complete believe on Kalma.He is not muslim he pray five time or 10 time useless & If U not Believe U can’t Call Ur Self Muslim & Ur Place Where U Pray Mosque or Masjid about what happened at ur place where u pray its not specially for u this what every Pakistani facing so don’t try to take advantages from the peoples or from out side.All the reply i saw frm ur own community.

      • Usman says:

        @Shafique Ahmed,

        Mr Shafique Ahmed, can you please tell me the meaning of Kalima in either english or urdu, also can you please tell me how you can find out who doesn’t beleive in Kalima?
        In addition can you please tell me what right you have to call one muslim or non muslim when the other person is calling him/her self muslim? Are you God? because only God knows what is inside one’s heart.
        Also i think you do not even know what Quran says about the defination of muslim. Do you read Quran? when you do, do you read the meanings? In Quran it says who ever belvies in Allah is muslim, When the video of the lahore mosque shown, did you not read the Kalima written inside the mosque? or is it that you probably can’t read kalima and only listen to what the jahil mullah teaches the jahil public of Pakistan

      • Shafique Ahmed says:

        @Usman, Do U Believe That Nabi s.a.w Is the Last Nabi & Rasool. Yes Or No From This Yes Or no I can Say Any 1 To Kaffir & further i know the meaning & i Read quran & also books of ahadith also, & I read translation also even my arabi is very good coz i read it as a language so 1st give me my answer then we can talk further.

      • muhammad Kashif says:

        @Shafique Ahmed, good reply

      • Atif Malik says:

        @Shafique Ahmed,
        Shafeeq sahib I don’t hold your ignorant views against you, as I said to Adeel sb below, the government of Pakistan forbids Ahmadi Muslims from preaching, publishing literature or any form of public declaration of our faith, hence allowing mullahs and haters to instead publish literature claiming what our beliefs are, and because it’s a book or leaflet you believe it, after all Ahmadis are not publicly stating otherwise (since we are not allowed to!). So I’m glad you bring this topic up as it validates the lies and propaganda against us. Brother, take a look at our website, http://www.alislam.org and you will see we have only ONE kalima, the same as yours; La illaha illala ho Muhammadar rasul-lolah. Apologies for any transliteration spelling errors, but hopefully you can read it.
        God be with you as you search the truth.

      • Shafique Ahmed says:

        @Atif Malik, Did U Believe That Rasool s.a.w Is The last Nabi & Rasool ?

      • Atif Malik says:

        @Shafique Ahmed, which part of the kalima don’t you understand. Prophet Muhammad saw if the last Nabi and rasool. We never question that. The Imam Mahdi doesn’t bring any new teachings or scripture, all his purpose is to redirect everyone to the Holy Quaran. That’s how misunderstood we Ahmadi Muslims are due to the silence imposed on us. We only look to act of the teachings of the Holy Quaran and spread the teachings of the Holy Quaran across the world. About qiyamat, it is around the corner, and we believe that, but in earth time meaning for the age of the world is close to it’s end, but in our life time it could be many life times away. Just try and make logical sense, the teachings say that the Imam Mahdi will spread the message around the world and a large part of the world will conver to Islam…this does not happen overnight.

      • Usman says:

        @Shafique Ahmed,
        I think you should answer what i said first if you want things to go ahead because you cannot ignore what i have said and start a new question, I repeat my question well actually how about i just copy paste it so even the words are same.
        “Mr Shafique Ahmed, can you please tell me the meaning of Kalima in either english or urdu, also can you please tell me how you can find out who doesn’t beleive in Kalima?”
        “In addition can you please tell me what right you have to call one muslim or non muslim when the other person is calling him/her self muslim? Are you God? because only God knows what is inside one’s heart.”

        So lets start from the begining instead of creating new questions without answering the previous ones.

  15. Hafiz Naveed Ahmad says:

    Atif May Allah bless you with more more & more knowledge, wisdom and power of writing to reveal the truth. A very Nice piece of writing representing all the Ahmadies… Keep it up brother.

  16. fawad says:

    u Quadiani group or the Lahori group or ahmadi wtf u guys call ur self are disgrace to all muslims…..near me u r worst then every single being in the planet…..just like a waliking piece of crap.

  17. Dear atif,
    u have expressed ur feelings very well on behalf of all ahmadis … But this law was made by zia ul haq … He himself was a corrupt man … A named muslim only so he has no right to declair any one non muslim … This right belongs to Allah only … Because he knws the reality of the hearts …there r many groups muslims r divided in shia sunni deobandi n many n every one consider them the right one but only Allah knws who is on the right path .. So we should only focus the holy Quran n Sunnah of the las Prophet S.A.W… WE ll automatically follow the correct group … We should b muslims only nor shia sunni ahmadi deobandi etc
    u wrote well .. I appreciate … Good work
    tc

    • M. ABID ALAM says:

      MIS G APNEY JHUTEY AUR GALIZ JIS KO AP MANTEY HO MIRZA GULAM JIS KO ALLAH NE IBRATNAK MOUT DI PHIR BHI ANKHEN BAND HAIN AP LOGO KI….. AFSOS HA…..

      • Bolo says:

        It sickens me to live in a country where oppression of faith is so freely practiced. Who decides what you believe is correct and what isn’t? Your beliefs are entirely yours. I think what the people of Pakistan don’t understand is that being a good person is more important than being a good Muslim. Humanity comes before religion. And what good are your beliefs if they cause you to kill and burn and cause harm to others? Shame on you, Pakistan.

      • AFIA REHMAN says:

        KAUNSI IBRATNAAK MOUT AAJ TAK PATA HAI K AAP (A.S.) KI WAFAAT KESE HOI THI AUR KITNE LOGON NE JANAAZA PARHA THA.IBRATNAAK MOUT TO HOI THI ZIA UL HAQ KI AUR INSHALLAH HOGI HR US SHKHS KI JO KHUDA KI IS JAMAT PR HAATH DAALE GA KIUNKE YE KHUD KHUDA TAALA KA WAADA HAI.

  18. great article..!
    Em shia muslim nd i was always told that we r frst humans thn muslims nd thn of sect which we belong..!
    As far as attacks of lahore concerns i dont consider thm humans (far frm muslims)..our teacher (hazrat muhammad pbuh) never told us to kill any othr human..!
    Qadiyanis are muslim or not let allah decide ths..!
    If any one says he his muslim let him say it is god who has to decide not any mullah or any corrupt political leader..!
    Why those mullahs nd learders dont say a word abt taliban??
    Anyone who supports the killing of innocent human is not muslim..! He is not human being, why dont they say ths??
    Nd lahore attack was nt the work of any muslim..!
    may the souls of all lahore victims rest in peace..!
    Allah hafiz
    Pakistan xindabad…!

  19. Adeel says:

    Dear Writer,
    Though your writing is great and has it has same pain which Muslims are facing. The peoblem with Qadiani/ Marzai / Ahmadei and all related people is that you people do not accept the ending of Prophecy. The last Prophet from Allah was Muhammad (SAW).
    You discussed about, bralvy, deobandi and all others. They have different beliefs but their base is the same. They all believe in the oneness of Allah and the Last prophet of Allah is Muhammad.
    Which you people dont and this is the base of Islam.
    Rest of the things, every body is facing the same problem in our part of the world, whether it be a muslim, hindu, christian or anyone else. so we all can just have hope that the time will change.

    • Atif Malik says:

      @Adeel,
      Actually the problem Adeel is that Ahmadi Muslims are by LAW not allowed to publish our views, so the majority of Pakistanis only read our opponents lies about us, and we not only are not allowed to publicly defend ourselves we also are forbidden from explaining ourselves as that is preaching which is illegal for us. please tell me where in Islam such barbaric measures are allowed to suppress a minority?
      On your point of oneness of Allah, of course that is our view.
      On finality of prophethood, we also believe prophet Muhammad s.a.w. is the Last Law bearing prophet. Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. himself prophecised of the Imam Mahdi and Promised Messiah, that is someone like Jesus was to the Moses, a reformer of Islam will come and his name will be Ahmad – that was his prophecy. We believe Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian, India was that man. We believe Prophet Muhammad is the highest of all Prophets and the final law bearing prophet. Personally don’t see the point of going in to being called a messiah or prophet, but our Hazur is the foretold reformer of Islam. He took the jihad of Islam, through the pen, e.g. against the Christians, articulating clearly why Jesus did not die on the cross, the fundamental basis of their faith and why in fact he came to reform the Jews, who mistakenly rejected him. Rather than seeing what and how Ahmadi Muslims are promoting Islam throughout the world we have mullahs (fearing their job not Allah) who have sealed our voice and propagate lies to distance the mainstream from us.

      Pray you have the strength and courage to open your heart and mind to the possibility of things not being what you thought. Go direct to the source to read what our views are and not the lies others will tell (www.alislam.org).

  20. Gul says:

    Salam elaikum,
    you have written a nice letter but you fail to realize that why qadianies are reffered as non-muslims. It is because that you do not accept that prophet Mohammad is last and final messenger of Allah. If you have proof of your claim that Mr. Qadiani is messenger of Allah in Quran or Sahih Hadees. Go to supreme court and prove it, judiciary is free today…
    If I claim today that I am prophet.. will you accept it??? wake up friends. just study Quran unbiased and InshaAllah you will know truth.
    I will pray Allah to give Hidayah to you. Ameen

    • Atif Malik says:

      @Gul,
      Please see my comment above to Adeel sahib, same applies to you.
      May Allah open your eyes and heart to the truth.
      Amen.

      • Bilal Shaikh says:

        @Atif Malik, beta read Gul’s message carefully… he said “Mr. Qadiani is messenger of Allah in Quran or Sahih Hadees. Go to supreme court and prove it, judiciary is free today…”
        anyone can make crodile tears in internet but prove yourself at front of the world.
        there is also a religion in world with the name “setan”- they belive on setan and worship him, and as we all believe that setan posses so what should a person do??? should he accept that religion????
        if you would be a muslim then ALLAH projected you and you would be able to express your voice independently not like choohas;-)
        open your eyes and ears jahil peoples!

      • Atif Malik says:

        @Bilal Shaikh, Your anger and evil intent needs attention, first and foremost. Regardless of your religious views, no where in any religion does it allow such hatred or evil intent. Allah is our Creator and Judge, I pity you for assuming you have the right to take His role. Your aggressiveness – telling me to shut my mouth, n later of being eligible to be killed proves how far away from Islam you are; the very word Islam means PEACE and SUBMISSION. Try that.
        As for the question on supreme court, thanks for asking. Ahmadis did go to court in 1973/4 and very well proved their case, however, the findings were never published because they (mullahs) did not have answers to our arguments. Instead, the court declared what the mullahs had demanded or face the bloodshed they threatened. Odd that such a supreme court judgement can be ruled, and yet no public record of the proceedings be available. Since then we are not even allowed to defend ourselves as tht very action would be blasphemy! Where Prophet Muhammad pbuh returned to Mekkah and never killed those that actually tried to kill him, you think he would applaud the actions of Pakistan government and mullah-followers? shame on you for failing so badly to understand the beauty of Islam. We Ahmadi Muslims are looking to spread the message of Islam throughout the world; translating the Holy Quaran in over 100 languages. Meanwhile we continue to over our backs as our own brothers look to not only silence us but kill us. Ina lilalhe wa ina aleyhay ra ji-oun.

      • Bilal Shaikh says:

        @Atif Malik, and muslims also believe that IMAM MEHDI will come but at the time of QAYAMAt and if your ahmad qadyan’s claim was true so why he died??????
        i advice you if you cant open your eyes and ears so please shut your mouth as well…. because we muslims dont like and bear amendment in our religion. you all are allowed to kill according to Islam because non-muslim could not be killed without any reason bot Apostasy(mortid- person who take amendement in islam) must be killed!!!!

    • sana says:

      @Gul, Funny thing…courts are unbiased…hahahahahha…first you make constitution and cruel laws against ahmadi’s and then say go to courts…you guys are awesome….
      Use your brains if you have them…
      hazarat abu baker on hazrat muhammed(saw) death said that “hazoor (saw) had died just like the other prophets have died before him….”
      sahaba’s(fellows of prophet muhammed(saw)) did’nt corrected him that no you are wrong hazrat esa(as) is not dead yet…so your ajamah of mullah cult means nothing to ahmadi’s…the ajmah of sahaba’s is authenticated…..

  21. Hussain says:

    Every thing was crystal clear in last khutba of Prophet Moahmmed (P.B.U.H), no need to go in to such tame wasting arguments…..

  22. Hussain says:

    Every thing was crystal clear in last khutba of Prophet Moahmmed (P.B.U.H), no need to go in to such time wasting arguments…..

  23. hussain says:

    awww thts bad…. but why do this law stops you people from calling your worship place a mosque? mean what is the objectionable deed they think you people do as a qadiani or ahmadi????

  24. Muzaffar Masood Malik says:

    Dear Atif
    I ve no words… i ve no words to explain my heartiest feelings… i ve no words to thank u… what can i do??? i think i cant do anything… but one thing i can do and that is DUA.. dua to my almighty allah for those innocent people of my community who is suffering all of this… and also i can pray to allah for those MULLAH and so called Muslims who are doing this just on the name of God and on the name of Islam… what is islam??? what islam teaches us??? this… that kill them and call it jahad… etc etc
    No NO No
    this is not islam.. this is not the real face of islam…Mullah totaly changed the picture of beautiful face islam… May Allah open there eyes, and give them rationality,knowledge and truth…

    Praying for our motherland.

    A fellow patriot,

    Muzaffar Masood Malik

  25. mubarik says:

    wel done, its awesome.

  26. Maryam says:

    Deen main koi jabar nai!! Aik insan ka katal puri insaniyat ka katal hai!! This is our religion ppl..these are the teachings of my beloved prophet Hadhrat Muhammad PBUH.. Love for all hatered for none!! Peace..

    • Hassan Khan says:

      @Maryam, magar qatil ka qatal Bilkul sahi hay…Gustakh e rasool ka qartal karna sahi hay….Ahmadio ka qatal karna sahi hay

      • Maryam says:

        Mr. Khan….kiya aap sari namazain parhtay hain?? kiya aap hamesha sach boltay hain?? kiya aap apne parents ka har kaha mantay hain?? kiya aap ne kabhi apni kissi bat se kissi ka dil nai dukhaya?? jawab mujhe se behtar aap ko khud pata hon gae.. agar nai to aap kaise musalman hain jo humaray piyara aaka Hadrat Muhammad PBUH ki kahi hoi baaton pe amal nai kartay!! pehle apne gairban main jhankain phir dosron ko baat karain.. Love for all Hatered for none!!

      • Ali Akber says:

        @Maryam,
        Im a bohra shia muslim and i completely agree with your reply miss Mariyum.

      • Maryam says:

        thank u very much Mr. Akbar..acha muslim banne k liye aik acha insan hona zaroori hai..par aise sooch k qatal ker do.. maar do ya khatam ker do…yeh kissi muslim ki sooch nai ho sakti..insan to dur ki bat hai..Allah humain hidayat de aur apni amaaan main rakhay..ameen..

      • sana says:

        @Maryam, Good job…..

  27. I’m glad to see all the comments and feedback. Jazakallah

    As far as arguments of being Muslim or non-Muslim is concerned that’s a theological debate and can’t be explained in few hundred words since hate for Ahmadi MUSLIMS is engraved on hearts of majority of Pakistanis by the one and only enemy of Humanity the Mullah Cult.

    The issue raised here is the issue of Hypocrisy of Pakistani media and bowing before the right wing Mullah pressure. They all refer to Ahmadiyya Mosques as Mosques OFF Camera, but its the otherwise on-record!

    There is NO LAW that restricts “Constitutional Musalamaans” of the so called “Islamic Republic of Pakistan” to call our mosque – a mosque!

    I would request all my non-Ahmadi Muslim brothers and sisters who would like to get into a theological debate to clear their understanding of faith first and then get into a debate. It’s useless to talk if you don’t know the basics.

    P.S This forum is NOT for theological debate. Kindly visit Rah-e-Huda Forum to get involved and clear your understanding about Islam Ahmadiyya http://rahehuda.mta.tv/index.php?option=com_kunena&view=listcat&catid=28&Itemid=102

    Regards
    Atif S Ahmad

  28. Hassan Khan says:

    Salam evry one..Plz dont fall into the trap of these qadianis…They are not muslims cuz they dont accept Prophet Muhammad as the last Messenger and Prophet…Qadianis are not muslims…thats a fact…And they are trying to change our minds by confusing us!
    We are muslims first..the servants of Allah and his messenger and then we are human beings…!
    And Shia sunni are different sects…not different believes,,, Ahmadis have a completely different believe just as christians or any other person has…Qadianis should be killed where ever found…There is no doubt in that!

    • @Hassan Khan, Yeah Keep on falling and bowing before the Mullah Cult. They’ll end up killing you and your families too.

    • Ali Akber says:

      @Hassan Khan,
      Mr. Hassan,

      Im a shia muslim. We beleive that qadianis are non muslims, but still why should they be killed ?? On what basis ? who gave you the right to kill any non muslim? Is this the teaching of our Holy Prophet S.A.W ?

      You should be ashamed of dis gracing ISLAM.

      • M. ABID ALAM says:

        OYE BAKWAS TUM SHIA TO SB SE MUTNAZEA MUSALMAN HO TUMHEN TO BOLNA HI NAHI CHAHYE…… AUR COMMENT KARNE KA TO SOCHNA B NAI APNA KAM KARO APNE KAYE PER SEENA PEETO ZANJEEREN MARO…. DUNIA MEIN B SAZA AUR AKHRAT MEIN BHI…

    • sana says:

      @Hassan Khan, dont fall in to the trap of hassan khan coz according to me he is a terrorist…he bealives in killing….that is the fact…he is imposing his confusions on you…
      Mr hassan you are also declared by other sects as a kafir…if you havent read their books…go on and read them…do not focus all you abilities on lying against ahmadis….God bless us all….

  29. Moiez says:

    @Hassan Khan,

    Illiteracy will be removed when u can read the views and teaching of both the oppressed and the oppressor and then decide whtever u want.
    I think one should come to any conclosion abt giving a fatwa abt muslim or non muslim, we are a mere humans created by God, its a dangerous act to challenge the God when u give such brainless fatwas. God is a best decider, we are not.

  30. @Hassan Khan, i feel really sorry fr u fr having such belives..! have you askd any mullah of urs that why killing of any qadyani is ryte when prophet pbuh never killed a single person??
    Killing of any human being is not allowed in any religion and u r talking shit that islam allows killing??
    Muslims are born to save humanity not to kill humanity..!
    Allah tmhy hiadayat dy..!
    Aur hm sb ko bardasht krny ka hosla ata farmaay..!

  31. Anjabeen says:

    I’m pleased that the young Ahmadis are finally thinking of raising a collective voice against the outrageous acts of the so-called muslims of this land we live in. However, I have lost hope.The few comments of the non-ahmadi readers only prove the extent of illiteracy and hostility that engulfs them. They are extremely ignorant. And extremely inhuman.
    But carry on the good work.It is high time we got together to make ourselves heard.

  32. Afaq Ahmed Zahid says:

    salam
    yar admin apko ye picture nai lagani chahye thi jo kay aik shadeed qarb ki halat main li gai thi jo kay khatoon ki hai jiska parda shiddat e gham ki waja say theek na rah ska..apko chahye tha kay koi aur picture is jaga lagaty…i hope you will think about this…

  33. Qasim says:

    With due respect to the writer and all, the article is a bit confusing. I do not belong to the Ahmaddiya community, but am utterly against the non-sense that they should be killed, blah blah, or other stupid tactics of violence propagated against them. As individuals, all should be granted the freedom to live as they desire. But my question is, do Ahmadis believe in the finality of the Prophet (PBUH)? Pardon my ignorance, and the link of the site posted above doesn’t work. Because if you don’t, then there’s no question of calling yourselves Muslims, and the problems that surround this community basically emanate from the same fact that how can you enter Islam, or say any other religion, without accepting its laws? If you don’t believe in the finality of the Prophet, then you can label your religion as a separate entity and that ought to be respected. Hoping to get an in-depth answer. Peace!

  34. Khalid OKS says:

    very well written , thou i’m not an Ahmedi Muslim , but I respect your sentiments.
    May Allah bless you. :) Ameen

    • M. ABID ALAM says:

      JB TU NE AHMADDI KI HIMAYAT KAR DI TO KESA MULIM HAI TU BAKWAS JA TU BHI RABWA DAFAN JO JA BADTAMEEZ….. AUR AHMADI KI RESPECT MEAM AP S.A.W.W KI NAFARMANI KIS TARHA KA MUSLIM…… HAMARY DEEN MEIN TERE JASE LOG HUEY TO DEEN KI SHKAL HI BIGAR JAYE GI…….

  35. Arif Mehmood says:

    Asalam O Alekum …. to all those who considers themselves MUSLIMS.

    @hassan khan : my dear bro u need to study ahmadi beliefs instead of accepting the lies of ahmadi beliefs propagated by Mullahs. i would advise u to visit the website : http://www.alislam.org , and get to know the real face of Ahmadiat.

    we believe in the finality of the prophethood in Muhammad SAW.

    i would like to give u some assignment. ask ur knowledgable Mullah/Scholar that wat our prophet pbuh said on the death of his beloved son hazrat ibrahim… that if he were to live he would have been a true nabi.

    therez an ahadis in which the holy prophet saw says that there shall be no Nabi between ‘me’ and ‘mahdi’ .

    the holy prophet muhammad s.a.w is the seal of the prophets. if there was any prophet to come, he will be required to be sealed and attested by the holy prophet s.a.w. he will bring no other shariah, neither any new religion. he will only spread the message of Allah and the prophet muhammad s.a.w.

    so my dear bro, we ahmadis just say that hazrat imam mahdi is being bestowed with the Inaam of Nabi. we seek ba’ait in his hands as being the prophesied Mahdi, and not being a Nabi. Instead we believe and have faith in hazrat muhammad s.a.w as our nabi, and believe in his teachings.

  36. Neena says:

    Assalam-o-Alaikum! Anyone who really wants to know the fact about Ahmadiyyat should follow this link. http://www.alislam.org/v/97.html

  37. Anny says:

    Arif mahmood.

    With you due respect I want to ask who was Mirza Ghulam Ahmad? promised Mesiah or promised mahdi?

  38. Farrukh says:

    Mr. Atif. i have heard that qayamat k nazdeeek jaisay jaisay logon ka imaan kamzor hota jaey ga to dajal aor us k perokaar aen gay. n dajal k anen say pahlay wo dunya main inti confusion paida ker dain gay k dajal k baray main log bhol jaen ga k ISLAM main dajal ka hulya aor us k kaam kaisay hon gay. kiun k ager hum sab ko yad rahay ga k dajal aisa ho ga aor yai chwalen maray ga to automatically hum us say door chalay jaen gay mager Mirz. qadiyani jaisay log jab Islam, Quran aor hadeeson ko apnen ap say mansoob kerna shuru ker dain gay to zahir hay confusion to aey gi na. QURAN ki AYAT hy..

    Bismillah alRehman alRaheem
    “MUHAMMAD is not the father of any man among you, but HE is the messenger of ALLAH and the last of the Prophets; and ALLAH is aware of all things”. (Quran, Al-Ahzab 33:40)

    ho sakay to iss ko Quran main perhna aor btana k iss k bad b kisi ahmadi ko kafir bulkay murtad nahi kahna chahiay..??? main to yai perh k e murtad kahta hon…
    ap logon k liay dua kertay hen k ALLAH ap logon k dilon say aor ankhon say perda hataey ta k ap log hidayat paa jaen.

    ALLAH hum sab ko fitna-ey qadiyaniat say bachaey ameen.

    Mr. atif i respect ur religion but if u try to call it islam then i m sorry mairay ilafz aor sakht ho jaey gay.

    ALLAH emaan pay mout day na ameen

    • sana says:

      @Farrukh

      Quran says:
      And relate the story of Ishmael as mentioned in the Book. He was indeed strict in keeping his promise. And he was a Messenger, a Prophet.
      maryam [19:55] اور (اس) کتاب میں اسماعیل کا ذکر بھی کر۔ یقیناً وہ سچے وعدے والا اور رسول (اور) نبی تھا
      Read this and tell me why a rasool and nabi is a different thing in this verse….why Allah mentioned both at a same time..if they are same…
      answer is simple and clear….
      explain it…if you cannot then stop claiming that you are the only muslim…

  39. waqas says:

    asalam u alikum Mr Farrukh…you just took words of my mouth..if i have read this “OPEN LETTER” before you, i might quote the same verse of holy Quran as you quoted…
    beside, as you have cleared the thing to their extent, i just want to add one thing for all people on this forum. what i personally feel from this letter is that this gentleman (mr. atif) must be in legal procedure of asylum in some country and it is obvious that ONE have to prove that “I REALLY DESERVE IT”…for that purpose one has to make fake/false stories of the religious discrimination, threat to life and lack of opportunities to earn a good living…although such people cause building of negative image about pakistan and muslims but please i request i request all Muslim (True muslims) to help him out as a human being…let him have asylum case won…because it is not the first time…it is happening since many decades that people of his religion faked to get donations from NGOs, get quotas for jobs and get asylum on these backgrounds…show him and other people of his religion that we muslims even have open hearts for the traitors like him

  40. Neena says:

    Ghairat ki ja he Isa Zinda ho Aasman per
    Madfoon ho zameen me Shah-E-Jahan hamara
    Think about it. to all who disbelief on the death of Hazrat Isa (A.S)
    If he is alive than how the HOly Prophet (Peace be Upon Him) can be the last prophet?

    • M. ABID ALAM says:

      APNI HAD MEIN RAHO MISS NEENA AGAR MUSALAN BHARAK GAYE ALLAH AP LOGO KO GARQ KAR DEGY AP LOG K MUSLAK AIK MQSAD K LYE HAI AUR WO SIRF YE K MUSLANO K DEEN KO MODERN KARNA JO K NAJAIZ HAI……

  41. Mahmood A. Tahir says:

    dear
    salutations,
    I have read the letter job well done. These Mullahs are full of mischief s and creating the disorder in our dear motherland. The holy prophet Muhammad Rasululla (SAW) has said about the later days so called Ulama that people will go to them to seek guidance over the matters they will find these Ulama like monkey and pegs they will mislead them. therefore today ummah is facing the same situation so called Ulama are misguiding the people on the name of Islam.
    This situation cannot be changed by itself until people will be ready to change what is in their minds.
    Everyone is following these so called Ulama without getting any correct knowledge about the matters.
    According Quranic teaching if somebody hears the any news so that individual must investigate about it before making any decision.

    May Allah give to my people such eyes so they can see them , give them such ears so they can hear the truth and give them such hearts which full of the fearness of Allah the almighty so they understand. Amin

  42. Raja says:

    ajj above discuss study ki he finally mayn yeh keh sakta hoyn ke ahmadis arguments were good according and to Islam.
    aur language high standard ki use ki gaye he.
    aur apne app ko muslman kene waloo ki language was very insulting
    har aik ke mazhab ka ihtram karna islami nazaryya he.
    allah Bless all who respect human and their beliefs.
    ahmadis are growing day by day in millions koy batt to he .

    • M. ABID ALAM says:

      HUM LOGO KO AP KAY MUSLAK SE KOI LENA DENA NAHI SIRF IS BAAT KI CHIRR HAI K AP LOG APNE NAPAK AQIDAY KO ISLAM NA KAHO OTHER WISE YE BADTAMEEZ HUM AUR MAZHAB SE KU NAHI KARTY….. WO IS LYE KE WO APNE MAZAHAB KO HUM SE NAHI MILATEY AUR RAHI BAT LANGUAGE KI TO YE TO KUCH BHI NAHI AGAR BHARK GAE NA MUSLAMAN TO ZUBAN TO KAYA TUM LOGO KA WAJOOB BHI NAHI RAHE GA SAMJHA………. RAJA SAHIB

  43. Dr Rasheed S Azam says:

    Let the light of truth and love of God burn in your heart and you shall never fail. We all have die one day and full accounting shall be presented before God Almighty.

  44. wo ghari ati ha esa pukaren ge mujhe ab to thore reh gaye dajal kehlane ke din

  45. hum to rakhte hain musalmanon ka deen dil se hain khudam khatm ul mursaleen.

  46. Abdullah says:

    im sorry you guys are probably way more learned and well read than me…but my sole argument is if you believe in another Prophet after our beloved last Prohet PBUH than your ruining our religion!!..I wouldnt mind at all if you were christians and not be distorting and disfiguring my religion ISLAM…so please realise the truth…If you read the Quran like you guys imply you do ….DO YOU NOT READ THE PART ABOUT THE LAST PROHET BEING MUHAMMAD PBUH!!!!
    or do you just go dumb blind n deaf

  47. Abdullah says:

    i honestly do pray to ALLAH for showing you the right path and giving you the courage and power to read the and understand the Quran and not go blind everytime the Quran mentions Muhammad PBUH as the last Prohpet of Allah!…please guys if you consider yourself that much smart please think about it…everythings infront of you

  48. Fatima ( Muslim ) says:

    “We are those that no matter how much others insult us or hurt & harm us, we never say or do anything hurtful back.”

    u ppl while insulting the Muslim community say so? incredible !!! isn’t it extremism that one call himself prophet of Almighty Allah? The one who was working under british Govt. to “insult” and ” harm” the Muslim community?

  49. ash bash says:

    dear all, we all are human and we cant decide who is righ or wrong,but reading all above i can say that ahmadies have the true knwldge of islam, they have not scolded a single MUSLIM, they argued with reason,plz try to understand that if we dont consider them even humans, how can we should be called muslims,,,our prophet never did this to anyone.we should not be extremists,,,,isi waja se mullahs kethrough koi muslim nahi hota,,,,,we teach extremism,,,freedom of expression matters my dears………………….

  50. awan6292 says:

    aaj kaal ya asaan formula hay kisi baat py aktlaaf ho to baat cheet sy hal karny ki bjy agly ka khoon kar2. 2nd hum apny aap ko nahi dhaty k humara iqlaaq humara Qirdar ksa hy humri zaat sy kisi ko takleef ponchti to ponchy par hum 2sroon mamlaat main zaroor hisa layna apna farz samjhty hain . humain apny apny mulak py or jo fraiz hain un py aaml krna chiy